Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

All-Star Selection Bias by Team, Top 10 Overachieving/Underachieving Managers

On a previous lunch hour, between bites of an All-P sandwich* I was wondering if there was a useable correlation between the number of All-Stars teams have and an expected number of wins. I thought if a team had a lot of all-stars and lower-than expected the wins, it might suggest a lackluster managing job. Higher than average wins per all-star, good managing. It turns out there actually is a very strong step up in average winning percentage for each incremental All-Star a team has. Roughly this: 1 All-Star – average winning percent of .458; 2 All-Stars, .501; 3 All-Stars, .542; 4 All-Stars, .557, and so on.

 

The problem with using this information is the incredible market bias in all-star selections. To be able to evaluate Yankees managers and Twins managers on common ground, each team’s positive or negative bias in All-Star selections has to be compensated for.

 

To do this, I counted the number of All-Star selections each year and totaled the number of total league wins. I then figured out each year’s average wins per all-star and applied this to each team’s winning percentage to determine the equitable number of all-stars each team should have had. Summing the actual number of All-Stars each team had historically and dividing this by the sum of equitable All-Stars historically creates an index value per team than can be used for the aforementioned manager evaluation.

 

Which team has the biggest bias in All-Star team selection? Do I really have to ask? Of course, it’s the Yankees with nearly 52% more All-Stars than a fair distribution suggests given the team’s success. This is by far and away the highest bias as the next closest team, the Cardinals, are at +23%. Rounding out the top 5 are the Red Sox at +21%, and the Dodgers and the Reds both at 13%. Conversely, the Rodney Dangerfield teams of All-Star selections are led by the Rays at -20%, the A’s and Astros at -19%, the Pirates at -18%, and the Royals at -17%. The Twins, if you’re curious, are at -15% which is 9th worst.

 

If you’re curious about which managers overachieved or underachieved in their careers relative to the number of All-Stars their teams had, (adjusted for All-Star bias) here are looks at the top 10 and bottom 10 calculated during today’s lunch hour between bites of a Waldorf salad. (Based on average seasonal difference between actual wins and expected wins – had to be the manager for the majority of a team’s games to be credited for that season, had to manage at least 5 seasons.)

 

The Good

 

1. Joe McCarthy +12.7 wins per season to expectation.

2. Billy Southworth +11.2 wins

3. Joe Girardi +9.9 wins

4. Bobby Cox +7.8 wins

5. Al Lopez +7.7 wins

6. Earl Weaver +7.7 wins

7. Walter Alston + 7.7 wins

8. Pete Rose + 6.7 wins

9. Billy Martin + 6.6 wins

10. Jimy Williams +6.5 wins

 

The Not-So Good

1. Connie Mack -12.2 wins

2. Jimmie Wilson -11.8 wins

3. Billy Meyer -9.7 wins

4. Preston Gomez -9.7 wins

5. Buddy Bell -9.3 wins

6. Ossie Bluege -8.1 wins

7. Fred Haney -7.7 wins

8. Del Crandall -6.5 wins

9. Manny Acta -6.1 wins

10. Mary Marion -6.0 wins

 

And finally a look at the Twins managers , ranked best to worst:

 

1. Billy Martin +6.7 wins

2. Frank Quilici +3.2 wins

3. Ron Gardenhire +1.5 wins

4. Gene Mauch +0.7 wins

5. Ray Miller -0.3 wins

6. Sam Mele -1.2 wins

7. Tom Kelly -2.4 wins

8. Cal Ermer -2.6 wins

9. Billy Gardner -3.9 wins

10. Bill Rigney -5.4 wins

* pastrami, prosciutto, provolone, peppers, poupon and pickles on pumpernickel

2 Comments

Recommended Comments

RedBull34

Verified Member

Now I'm hungry...

beckmt

Verified Member

Remember every team has to have 1 All Star(rules may have changed).  Do not know how much this changes your calculation.

Guest
Add a comment...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.